Based on an excerpt from a podcast with Steven Rothberg, founder of The College Recruiter, this article shares his perspective on how job boards revolutionised recruitment by building on the classified ad model. It examines key benefits, challenges, and future trends in recruitment technology. It also explores the advantages and challenges they introduced.
In particular, we’ll explore the nuances of the duration-based job board pricing model and why it may not be the most effective solution for modern recruitment.
The evolution from print to online job ads
Before the rise of job boards, recruiters relied heavily on newspaper classified ads to reach potential candidates. These ads were limited in scope and accessibility, as job seekers had to flip through physical pages to find opportunities. Steven Rothberg explains, “When job boards came along, essentially what we did is we took newspaper classified ads and put them online.”
This transition solved a major issue by digitising the job ad process and making listings searchable, opening new doors for employers and candidates. Steven highlights one of the key benefits: “Those ads then became searchable. You could keyword search, you could filter them a lot easier than flipping pages and going through different columns.” However, he also notes that “the quality of search has always been a struggle,” underscoring a challenge that persists even today.
The benefits of online job boards
One of the primary advantages of moving classified ads online was the ability to search by keywords and filter results, allowing job seekers to find relevant positions more quickly. This shift brought efficiency to job seekers and recruiters, paving the way for more targeted hiring processes. Employers could target the right audience with greater precision, theoretically reducing the time and effort spent on recruitment.
Additionally, online job boards provided continuous exposure. Unlike newspaper ads with a limited run, online listings were accessible 24/7, potentially attracting more applicants over a more extended period. This always-on nature of job boards was a game-changer in recruitment marketing.
Decoding duration-based job ads
While online job boards brought undeniable benefits, they weren’t without their drawbacks. Steven highlights the duration-based pricing model as one of the key challenges. “At the end of the day, whether anybody saw your ad or not, whether anybody responded to it or not, or whether you hired anybody, you paid the same amount,” he explains.
Duration-based pricing models have been a foundational part of job boards since their inception, closely mimicking the payment structures of traditional print classified ads. This pricing structure has the advantage of simplicity and predictability but introduces several limitations.
How duration-based pricing works
In a duration-based model, recruitment agencies purchase a listing slot on the job board, which stays live for a fixed period. The cost of the listing is predetermined, and whether the job post gets one application or hundreds, the price remains the same.
Advantages of the duration-based model
- Simplicity: One of the most significant advantages of duration-based pricing is its simplicity. Recruiters know exactly what they are paying upfront and can plan their recruitment budget accordingly. However, it’s not always predictable, as job boards update pricing yearly.
- Predictability: Recruitment agencies can forecast recruitment expenses without worrying about fluctuating costs. For agencies that post jobs regularly, this provides a level of financial stability.
- Control over timing: Recruiters decide how long their ad will be live, ensuring continuous exposure for roles that may require a longer hiring cycle.
Drawbacks of the duration-based model
While there are clear benefits to the duration-based model, there are also several inherent drawbacks that limit its efficiency in modern recruitment.
- No performance guarantee: The biggest flaw of this model is the lack of performance-related pricing. Agencies pay a set fee regardless of how well the ad performs, whether it receives no views or an influx of irrelevant applications.
- Paying for unused time: If a position is filled early, recruiters still pay for the remaining time the ad is live, leading to wasted budget on unnecessary exposure.
- Saturation risk: If an ad remains live too long, it risks losing visibility as new job postings push it further down the list. As a result, an ad may only get high visibility in the first few days and taper off after that, reducing the value of the paid duration.
- No optimisation based on results: Duration-based ads offer little room for adjustment based on performance. If the ad isn’t attracting suitable candidates, recruiters have to wait until the end of the posting period or pay for additional exposure.
The shift towards performance-based models
Due to the inefficiencies of duration-based pricing, many recruiters and job boards are shifting towards performance-based models. In these models, payment is tied to specific actions, offering more employer and job board accountability.
- Pay-per-click (PPC): Employers only pay when a candidate clicks on their job ad, ensuring they pay for engagement rather than simple visibility.
- Pay-per-application (PPA): Some platforms allow employers to pay when a candidate submits an application, aligning the cost with tangible recruitment results.
- Pay-per-hire: In this model, payment is made only when the employer successfully hires a candidate from the job board, making it a highly performance-driven pricing strategy.
These performance-based models address the inefficiencies Steven identified, focusing on results over visibility. They offer a more cost-effective solution for employers, as they pay directly for results rather than a fixed duration.
What’s next for job ads?
As job boards evolve, the recruitment industry increasingly focuses on enhancing job ads’ visibility, optimising relevance, and providing recruiters with better ROI through innovative tools and smarter strategies. Moving away from duration-based models towards performance-driven pricing could help bridge the gap between cost and results. AI and machine learning are also transforming the job board landscape, offering smarter search functions that better match candidates to jobs, and helping employers reach the right talent faster and more efficiently.
The transformation of job ads from print classifieds to online job boards has been pivotal in recruitment. While job boards offer unparalleled accessibility and searchability, duration-based pricing models remain challenging. The lack of performance guarantees and the risk of wasting money on underperforming ads make it a less-than-ideal solution for modern recruitment needs. As performance-based models gain traction and job board technology advances with AI and machine learning, recruiters are discovering more effective ways to connect with suitable candidates at the right time.
Buy and manage job board contracts with ease
We offer the best deals and appropriate packages for your candidate attraction requirements reducing overall recruitment media spend and driving candidates’ attention to you.
